"She was being haunted by herself."
Writer: Robert Shearman
Format: Novel
Released: October 2025
Series: Big Finish Novelisation 02
Featuring: Eighth Doctor, Charley
Synopsis
"Twas the night before Christmas, and all through the house not a creature was stirring..."
But something must be stirring. Something hidden in the shadows. Something which kills the servants of an old Edwardian mansion in the most brutal and macabre manner possible. Exactly on the chiming of the hour, every hour, as the grandfather clock ticks on towards midnight.
Trapped and afraid, the Doctor and his companion, Charley, are forced to play detective to murders with no motive, where even the victims don't stay dead. Time is running out.
And time itself might well be the killer...
Verdict
The Chimes of Midnight was an outstanding novelisation of one of the very best Big Finish audio dramas there is! I was so excited when these novelisations were released because it's just such a wonderful idea and a whole new way to enjoy a story that's as good as this one. I would go as far as saying that this is a perfect Doctor Who adventure across any format. It really is astonishingly good and I was intrigued to see how it would fare in prose, but it absolutely succeeds just as well which is a huge compliment! That strange and eery feeling was very much present which is a magnificent feat without any complimenting sound effects. I also thought the characterisation of the Eighth Doctor and Charley was tremendous and it's wonderful that this pairing get a full length book together. I think it's great that in what are hopefully just the first Big Finish novelisations that we get pairings exclusive to Big Finish. If this is a reader's first time introduction to Charley as companion then it's a great one! Sure, it would be beneficial to know the backstory of what happened in Storm Warning with her being saved from the R101 despite history recording her as dead, but I feel that was more than explained here which was magnificent. The titular story is actually one of very few audios that I have listened to more than once and that's down to the Covid Tweetalong so the story elements were certainly familiar, although I completely forgot that Edward Grove being alive was referring to the Edwardian house! I feel like I remembered just before reading the word that served as the revelation and I was kicking myself for forgetting. Twice! It's just an incredible setup and the story does a better job than any other in being suited for the Doctor and companion that feature. The Eighth and Charley are the epitome of Edwardian so the staff here were fantastic characters to go alongside them. Mr Shaughnessy as the butler is quite someone with how committed to the role he is and the bluntness everybody had towards Edith (or sometimes Mary) as the scullery maid actually became a tad say. They really did see everybody as just the sum of their role in the house, and the murders occurring was not a sad occasion to them but more so an inconvenience to the running of the household. Especially at Christmas! Despite the published date, I read this two weeks prior to Christmas so I was feeling festive which I do think would have helped enhance my enjoyment of what is already a classic! Mrs Baddeley is a fine character and it just wouldn't be the novelisation without it not being Christmas without her famous plum pudding! I think that's become such an iconic phrase and I just love it. The description of her murder with her being stuffed full of her own plum pudding is definitely the most gruesome of the bunch! Well, either that or Mary with her knitting needles stabbed into her head and her walking like antennae. I think the emotion that comes from the paradox breaking as Charley remembers Edith and her being saved and therefore Edith not committing suicide to join her in death is incredible stuff. It was presented so strongly in prose which was impressive. Charley professing her love for the Doctor throughout the book is a stark reminder of her feelings early on in her travels and the way she was teased throughout for him not feeling the same way provided a lot of sympathy. I could say so much more but I'd probably just be repeating previous feelings on story elements from the two blog entries I already have published of the audio format of this story. But just what a joy to read. Quite simply divine. It absolutely works in prose just as well as it did on audio and that might just be the biggest compliment I can give it. A perfect story.
Rating: 10/10



