"There are many lies in war."
Writer: Tim Foley
Format: Audio
Released: July 2026
Series: Rutans vs Sontarans 1.04
Featuring: Eighth Doctor, Charley, C'rizz
Synopsis
On the precipice of peace it stands...
After the destruction of a major stronghold, the Sontarans propose something extraordinary. More extraordinary still, the Rutans say yes. The Doctor, Charley and C'rizz are on hand to watch history being made.
Yet history has other ideas. A plan that has taken centuries is about to come to fruition. The Melmoth is returning.
Verdict
Peace at Last was an excellent episode to conclude the first series of Rutans vs Sontarans! This has been a terrific quartet of stories that has really done a fine job of exploring the eternal war between the Rutans and the Sontarans. I mean, the names were just switched around so this is the second series of the same premise in my opinion but I really hope we get another! There's so much potential and a huge playground of war to play around with when it comes to these two foes. This gave us a strong explanation of why the Eighth Doctor was popping up in Rendition and Grave Moon that actually made sense as instead of aiding Melmoth as she thought, he was actually tampering with her bomb that would see all of the Rutan Host separated from the collective. Her scheme was dastardly and I must admit I didn't see the reveal of her being Selina Carr coming! That was a really strong moment as she was a fun character throughout in the form of a news reporter. I really liked that we returned to an old faithful trio of the Eighth Doctor, Charley and C'rizz and even though I have been playing catch up for over a decade, this felt like a nice bit of nostalgia. I thought C'rizz was utilised really well with his nature being comparable to that of the Rutan but he was the only one of his kind in the universe and that really did mean something here. He was able to be reasoned with slightly with the Rutan and that made him a strong companion for this series. The very idea of a peace treaty between the Sontarans and Rutans is pretty much unfathomable so hearing that play out in the pre-credits was quite spectacular. It was clear the Sontarans in particular were never going to see a ceasefire as honourable, but just the fact they were using it as a plan was excellent. General Greff was an intriguing character in the Sontaran chain of command and him being the driving force behind a massacre of over 200,000 Rutan force with his codename was terrific. He was the driving force behind not actually seeking peace and I'm actually surprised any of the Sontaran kind would entertain the idea, especially considering some had been cloned specifically for the peace talks! That really is a change from the norm. The Doctor having memories of his involvement in Rutan poetry was great and a fun callback and I really liked how Melmoth was almost confused and angered by his lack of memory of his involvement in her life. Of course, it had yet to happen for the Eighth Doctor at this point in his life but we soon heard all that play out very nicely. I loved that he reminisced on seeing some old friends in the form of Zoe and Peri too. A really nice touch. The idea of Melmoth getting the perfect death and reuniting her with the collective to go into peace was quite something, but that would prove problematic as her memories returned. Memories in particular of the events of Betrayal at the House of Sontar where Division kickstarted the war and caused her so much harm. Hearing Melmoth actually mutter the word division but the Doctor not recognising that she was saying it capitalised was fantastic! He obviously thought she meant the division between herself and the Rutan collective but that was far from the case. She blamed him and it's staggering to think of the scale of her very existence. She really has had an eternity of suffering and she didn't exactly get a happy ending! Overall, a really strong finale to what has been a brilliant series. I hope we get more with these two races because they're just terrific! A tremendous listen.
Rating: 9/10



















