"You're listening to voices from the past."
Writer: Bob Ayres
Format: Audio
Released: May 2026
Series: BBC Audio 33
Featuring: Eleventh Doctor, Amy, Rory
Synopsis
Hello, I'm the Doctor... Doctor someone... can't remember who at the moment. Hoping it will come back to me.
On a planet with twin suns, three people wake in the shadow of a crashed spaceship. They don't know who they are or where they are. All they have to go on is a photograph of themselves marked 'Amy and her boys: Rory and the Doctor'. It's obvious who Amy is – but which of them is the Doctor?
A voice recorder in one of their pockets reveals how the TARDIS materialised some days earlier in the centre of a stone circle and the travellers met blue-skinned Sunaya, apparent sole survivor of the crashed ship.
Yet Sunaya isn't who she claims to be, and she is also far from alone. She and her children have been waiting to feed on the memories and identities of the living.
And as their own memories fade, the Doctor, Amy and Rory are in danger of being left behind for ever...
Verdict
Circle of Memory was a great story to serve as the latest release from BBC Audio! These audio originals are always welcomed and they almost feel like a version of the Past Doctor Adventures novels as it was lovely to dip back into the era of the Eleventh Doctor, Rory and Amy. They're a wonderful trio and I think their dynamic in Seres 5 is really intriguing because Amy and Rory are obviously due to be married, but there's definitely a romantic connection between the Doctor and Amy. Awkward. I thought the way that was addressed here was fun as it's clear events are still not too far removed from The Vampires of Venice as things remain new for our resident nurse. I think that's a good place to position a story, but I'm not sure it was right to be this kind of adventure. In fact, other than a little bit of humour at the start about who was Amy's fiancé out of the Doctor and Rory, I would have done this story with almost any other TARDIS trio. I just think the vibe and the whole playing with memory and reality thing feels awfully similar to what happened in Amy's Choice. And with this being early in Rory's travels it just has a feeling of sameness and I'm not sure continuity will allow for it to fit here. I liked the mystery format of the episode and having the Doctor, Amy and Rory not able to remember who they were was a fun dynamic. The Doctor being chuffed at them apparently working out that it was him that always got the date with Amy was amusing as I ca just picture that smug and cheesy look of the Eleventh Doctor. The Standing Stones were a really interesting concept and it was definitely one that I enjoyed. They reminded me of Stonehenge a little in terms of their significance but here on the twin-sunned planet they were literally storing and recording memories. I love that idea and playing around with memory in general has a lot of potential. So to have the Doctor also suffering from the loss is good and shows that things are pretty darn serious. Sunaya was a strong character and Rory being encouraged to work out what was happening with her was terrific. It felt like a strong episode for him in terms of recognition and establishing himself as more than just Amy's fiancé. Sunaya being the one to sent the distress signal from the ship crash was fun because it wasn't exactly the form of Sunaya we were expecting! I think the description of memories capturing time is rather beautiful and listening/blogging to this episode whilst on a family holiday really hit home for me as I'm making countless of them that I can't wait to look back on in many years to come. The Doctor using the sonic screwdriver because it was instinctual to do so was good fun and I thought Dan Starkey did a solid effort in bringing this incarnation and his companions to life with his impressions. Sure, they needed work but the effort and of the accent was impressive. The whole concept of telepathic abilities being used carnivorously was honestly incredible and I aways appreciate something unique! The Standing Stones actually being on hand as the local population's answer to a backup was really clever. I thought that worked nicely and the whole recording format of the episode was strong. Some tele-recordings though! Sunaya actually being an imposter was a strong revelation and I liked how she was trying to claim her innocence almost in revealing that everything they were doing was for their children. It was a refreshing change that they were genuinely doing what was best for their race. The TARDIS pre-empting events by landing in the stones and having them shortly wake up was brilliant. A backup was made immediately! The Doctor's blue clone almost becoming too much like the Doctor because of his memories was fun as it provided the means for a resolution regarding the children. Using the TARDIS, it could feed them the memory of the old planet that would see them right for some times with the power there! Overall, a terrific little audio adventure!
Rating: 8/10

















