"They fooled themselves."
Writer: John Dorney
Format: Audio
Released: April 2026
Series: Rutans vs Sontarans 1.01
Featuring: Fugitive Doctor
Synopsis
There are many stories of the Sontaran-Rutan war. But one hidden thread has yet to be revealed. A tale told across millennia. From before the war to its possible end. As the Doctor is about to discover...
On the run from the mysterious organisation called Division, the Doctor has come to the planet Sontar – home of the Kaveetch Empire and their armed forces, the Sontarans. She wants sanctuary... and she's offering the secrets of the Time Lords in exchange.
But with the whole of time and space up for grabs, the stakes are high. Can everyone on Sontar be trusted?
Verdict
Betrayal at the House of Sontar was an excellent start to the brand new Rutans vs Sontarans series! Well, let's be honest though, it's basically series two of the Sontarans vs Rutans spinoff we got two years ago! I can't believe they've just switched the name order and referred to it as an entirely new series in terms of numbering, but these are just semantics I'm complaining about because the story itself was just excellent. A depiction of how the ancient and enduring war between the Sontarans and the Rutan Host began! At last we get the origin and I thought it was tremendous. It was so close to full marks from me but this was a joy to listen to. I love the mystery of the Fugitive Doctor era and I think this definitively puts her incarnation prior to the First Doctor which is still not something I'm entirely sure I agree with, but with the Doctor being a time traveller that's no issue and it still keeps the continuity of The Sontarans in tact for me because she could just be at an early point in Sontaran history. I really appreciated the continuity this episode had with The First Sontarans and hearing the name Kaveetch again brought some memories flooding back! That Lost Story was one of my most anticipated when I started listening through Big Finish so it has some strong nostalgia for me. I can't believe it's twelve years since I blogged it! But going back to it was really well done. I thought Jo Martin was wonderful again as the Fugitive Doctor and it was pretty amusing for her to unknowingly foreshadow her future as the cover story had her on the run from Division as a fugitive. She laughed off that idea as unreasonable which is great knowing where things go for this incarnation. Drammal was a really strong character as a senior figure within Division and he was definitely one step ahead of the game in orchestrating events. He was always in control or so it felt and that made him a fascinating character. His role in taking out the Kaveetch was impressive and the Doctor was actually concerned by his actions. That said a lot as this version of the Doctor isn't quite the one we know despite there being signs and glimpses. I thought General Stahl was great as a Sontaran and I just adore the design depicted on the cover art. It's simply glorious! I also really liked Vrag and the humour that we often associate with the Sontarans wasn't so evident in this story which I admired because this felt very serious. It also felt incredibly alien for the Sontarans to not know who the Rutan Host were! That was really uneasy and showed us just how early in continuity we were knowing the span of that eternal war. I loved it. Having a Rutan Host aiding Division was fascinating too as there really is no issues of species when it comes to who is part of this secret Time Lord society. The Sontarans and Kaveetch being wary of the Time Lords was really good stuff and showcased their power with the rumours of species being wiped from time despite their apparent policy of non-intervention! Meredit appearing earlier in his life was an intriguing development too and just helped this story be a showcase of Sontaran continuity. I thought that was really good and I was then quite surprised by how Drammal orchestrated the conclusion in destroying the Kaveetch but ensuring the Sontarans remained. The concept of Division being the ones to create the war between Sontarans and Rutan Host by pitting them against the other as the perfect enemy to keep them busy in conflict because of the fears of Kaveetch technological advances with time travel is pretty incredible. Overall, a superb listen!
Rating: 9/10


















